The theme. Who order the Valladolid Debate to take place? Wilson's presidenct brought about increases in Civil rights organizations. Also increased criminal rights with his rulings in Mapp v Ohia, Gideon v Wainwright, Escobedo v Illinois, and Miranda v Arizona. Even today, the President cannot declare war without the 2/3 approval of Congress. E. but also in managing. Domingo Soto selected arguments by Las Casas and Seplveda in order to submit a summary of topics to them, before a final meeting of the Council of the Fourteen held in 1551. The rhetorical and ethical-legal precepts on which the topics from the debate were based reinforced the metaphysical principle of law, politics, and ethics of the Hispanic monarchy, which governed the conquest of the New World. [19], In Brevsima relacin de la destruccin de las Indias (1552), Las Casas's critique of the Spanish military forces in the New World, was one of the starting points of the Black Legend of Spanish colonisation. This preview shows page 1 - 2 out of 3 pages. AP is a trademark registered by the College Board, which is not affliated with, and does not endorse, this website. The majority of Democratic-Republicans switched views to Federalistic ideals like the support of a national bank. Helped bring about the increase of money in circulation. The positions supported by Bartolom de Las Casas and Juan Gins de Seplveda, in front of the junta of theologians and jurists in Valladolid in 1550, reflect the predominant division in the sixteenth century between theories attempting to define the humanity of the Indians and the terms of the conquest of America. First written constitution for the USA. Whilst Las Casas primarily argued on theological grounds, Seplveda held a rather more secular line in his argumentative style, in particular by invoking Aristotles definition of the barbarian and natural slave. Valladolid Debate Concerned the treatment of natives of the New World. The drama was played on a stage[27] in Spokane, Washington in January 2019. [24], In recent years, the Valladolid debate has been noted for its role (albeit marginal) in the conception of international politics in the sixteenth-century. Ex; freedom of speech, right to bear arms, right to a jury and a speedy trial, etc. thatrelatetotheValladoliddebateclaimsandcounterclaims. During the colonial period, Native Americans and enslaved Africans adapted their native cultures to that of __________________ in a variety of ways. The latter argued for peaceful proselytizing among them without force and to view them as rational beings (the Pope recognized them as such in 1537 in in the papal bull Sublimis Deus)**. Ex Post Facto. It is simplistic because all imperialist conquests have taken an equally traumatic form and continue to do so". Also ruled that the Missouri Compromise was unconstitutional for forbidding slavery in the north. [20] The slave trade was never explicitly mentioned in Las Casas's works, because he was an advocate for freedom and equal rights for all men, without distinctions of country or skin color. In recent years, the Valladolid Debate has resurfaced among legal scholars in particular, who wants to consider the affair in connection to the question of the Taliban and other terrorist groups. This led to patriots wanting to sperate from the British homeland. This set blacks to a sub human status which would later be fought over to change. View PDF. In Spain, it served to establish Las Casas as the primary, though controversial defender of the Indians. [4], Though Las Casas tried to bolster his position by recounting his experiences with the encomienda system's mistreatment of the Indians, the debate remained on largely theoretical grounds. The native peoples and enslaved Africans did what they could to continue to live life as they believed, while surviving __________________. In 1492, Columbus sails the ocean blue and establishes contact between two worlds, the New World and the Old World, and this contact would change things forever. Tobacco fields will later need to be farmed by labor (African slaves) and provide exrra incentive to increase colonization of a now profittable east coast. During the convention, Congress was given the power to delcare war, with 2/3 in both houses needed to declare wa. And this debate raged on in Spain and in the New World. Slavery was both a spiritual and temporal crime that missionaries fought in general, and that Las Casas in particular considered a mortal sin. A rigid class system, the encomienda system, divided people by their race. A joint stock company, the Virginia Company, funded the the creation of the first English colony, Jamestown. Please ask your students to join. Then tell in what discipline (medical or legal, for example) each word is more likely to be used. This set the trend in northern America to treat natives poorly. Interestingly, such concerns did not apply to __________________ in many Europeans' eyes. Course Hero member to access this document. 1993-2001. Jefferson said it was for the greater good of America and congress passed the purchase. As the leading European power in the 16th century, Spain had become a formidable force, giving its rivals a reason to try and discredit them in their intercolonial conflict. by 1830a all states established a principle of seperation of church and state. Essentially, neither side won nor lost and not much changed after the debate. With no law or leader, Sepulveda believed that they were freely available to be appropriated. The First 10 amendments, in the constitution, guaranteeing basic personal freedoms and protection from the abuse of government. "Many students confused chronological sequencing,". El problema racial en la conquista de Amrica y el mestizaje. Bartolome mainly argued on theoretical grounds. Have all your study materials in one place. This continued the mistreatment of natives by white people. Hernanzed, Bonar Ludwig. Young Democratic-Republicans, such as Clay and Calhoun, elected into congress. Bartolome was the first Spaniard, and by default, the first European, to begin to advocate for the rights of the Native Americans in the New World. Republican Mckinley defeats Populist William Jennings Bryan. Form of colonists self governing and a start to a constituition signed on the Mayflower. This allowed blacks to vote during the beginning of Reconstruction. All blacks were able to vote following the Civil Rights movement of the 1960s with the foundation being set with the 15th Amendment. Essentially, Sepulveda was saying that the indigenous populations, because of their barbaric practices, were unfit to govern themselves and they needed a European government to rule over them. Playing at Theatre de lAtelier and directed by Jacques Lassalle, La controverse de Valladolid (The Valladolid Debate) charts the confrontation between the Dominican Bartolome de Las Casas (Jacques Weber) and the philosopher Sepulveda (Lambert Wilson) under the authority of a Papal legate (Bernard Verley). Extracting profit from the land required teaching native peoples certain ________________ and ____________ skills. Everything you need for your studies in one place. Casas set a tone of establishing basic rights for Native Americans. [1] Las Casas objected, arguing that Aristotle's definition of barbarian and natural slave did not apply to the Indians, all of whom were fully capable of reason and should be brought to Christianity without force or coercion. 0 Reservationists wanted changes made to the peace agreement. Identify your study strength and weaknesses. Bartolomes argument achieved some success in 1550 when the king halted the forced expansion of Spanish territories in the Americas until the revisions of its moral implications. This is important because the majority, the middle class, were beginning to have a say in decisions of the country. He explained that he had been careless in believing that the Africans were rightfully enslaved, and declared that the treatment of the African slaves was as unfair and inhumane as the treatment of the Indians. Answer each question in a complete sentence that uses a word from the word web. Republican Warren Harding's presidency only lasted two years after he died in office in 1923. How did it come to be? Let's take to look the Valladolid Debate of 1550, the first ethics debate of European colonization. It concerned two main attitudes towards the conquest of the Americas. 01.03 The Valladolid Controversy - Step1CloselyreadandannotatetheSeplvedaandLasCasasdocuments.Highlightlines thatrelatetotheValladoliddebateclaimsandcoun, 37 out of 38 people found this document helpful. We have a memory produced by Soto himself, published in 1552, in the form of a transcription, in which he not only describes the scene of the disputation, but also establishes its character as a theological, rhetorical, and political model to emulate. In reality, it was a mechanism for their enslavement and for opportunistic people to shore up power and wealth as landlords. $$ [1] Las Casas represented one side of the debate. The encomienda system is a labor system established by the Spanish Crown in the 1500s. Sepulveda differed from Las Casas through his following of Aristotelian ideas surrounding slavery. He demands the immediate integration of public schools in the south. Held in the Colegio de San Gregorio, in the Spanish city of Valladolid, it was a moral and theological debate about the conquest of the Americas, its justification for the conversion to Catholicism, and more specifically about the relations between the European settlers and the natives of the New World. Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. Issues arose: government struggled collecting taxes, little united action to fend off potential enemies, This created a need for a new constitution. In 1794, Jay's Treaty involved Chief Justice John Jay. It was a very important debate and the whole country watched it. Seplveda, a humanist lawyer born in 1490, was an important figure in the court of Charles V where he served as the Emperor's chaplain and his official historian. A Dominican friar, he argued for the defense of the Indigenous peoples of America and the end of the encomienda system. My name i s Mr. Z emai t i s and I am l ooki ng f orward t o worki ng wi t h you t hi s f al l . Bartolome de las Casas sought to end the Spanish conquest of the Americas, which did not happen. This causes a shift in American polical policy creating a War on Terror. Aristotle believed that certain groups of people that were 'natural' enslaved people and that slavery were a beneficial transaction for all parties involved. A controversial theologian, Dominican friar and Bishop of Chiapas Bartolom de las Casas, argued that the Amerindians were free men in the natural order despite their practice of human sacrifices and other such customs, deserving the same consideration as the colonizers. Variety is a part of Penske Media Corporation. Columbus gains financing for his voyage from Europe to the Indies from the King and Queen of Spain. Digital Strategist. This set a relationship that continued up to the Seven Years' War against the English colonists and England. Formed a politcal alliance with poor whites and blacks, attacked pure capitalism. His election in 1964 led to his implementaion of a Great Society which ended segregation in the south and federalized health care for the old and poor. Bartolome de las Casas, a Dominican friar, argued in favor of the indigenous peoples of America and the end of the encomienda system; while Juan Gines de Sepulveda, prominent philosopher and theologian, supported the colonists, landowners, and conquerors who benefitted from the encomienda system. Established how a presdient should act, as a aleader. [14] According to Lewis Hanke, while Seplveda became the hero of the conquistadors, his success was short-lived, and his works were never published in Spain again during his lifetime. Warning: Parameter 1 to wp_default_styles() expected to be a reference, value given in /wp-includes/plugin.php on line 601 Warning: Parameter 1 to wp_default_scripts . Washington declared the USA neutral in the matter. Summoned in 1550 by Emperor Charles V to the chapel of the Colegio San Gregorio, before a junta of renowned theologians including Domingo Soto, Melchor Cano, Bernardino de Arvalo, members of the Council of . APUSH TV 10,299 views Sep 28, 2017 101 Dislike Share Save Apprend 551 subscribers Learn about the Valladolid Debate- a. a ruler with complete authority over the government and the lives of the people. Both opposed the ratification of the Treaty of Versailles. Soto, Domingo, Aqui se contiene una disputa, o controversia: entre el Obispo don fray Bartholome de las Casas, o Casaus, obispo que fue de la ciudad Real de Chiapa, que es en las Indias, parte de la nueva Espaa, y el doctor Gines de Sepulveda Coronista del Emperador nuestro seor [] Sevilla, Casa de Sebastian Trujillo, 1552. [22] His claims were confirmed by the posthumous publication of Las Casas's Historia de las Indias in 1875. Both Kansas and Nebraska, which were above the 36 30 line, would be formed and popular sovereignty would decide slave status in both the states. Declared that all American-born people were citizens and gave equal protection of the law and due process of the law to all citizens. Spanish settlers who were in charge of the natives working on the encomiendas. Spanish colonization had two intertwined aims________and __________. Third, the same went for human sacrifice. King Charles I ordered a debate in the Spanish courts to help settle and resolve the moral and theological issues that involved the encomienda system and the treatment of the indigenous peoples of America. He also argued that even with the practice of human sacrifice, any war that would erupt through forced conversion would be more harmful than ritual practice. Summoned in 1550 by Emperor Charles V to the chapel of the Colegio San Gregorio, before a junta of renowned theologians including Domingo Soto, Melchor Cano, Bernardino de Arvalo, members of the Council of Castile and the Council of the Indies, and officers of the Spanish government, they had to provide an answer for the question of a just war against the Gentiles. Valladolid debate (The) | EHNE. John Lund, Paul S. Vickery, P. Scott Corbett, Todd Pfannestiel, Volker Janssen, Eric Hinderaker, James A. Henretta, Rebecca Edwards, Robert O. Self. Historical Context of the Valladolid Debate. $$ [4], Seplveda put forward many of the arguments from his Latin dialogue Democrates alter sive de justi belli causis,[6] to assert that the barbaric traditions of certain Indians justified waging war against them. The war gave Britain the impression that the colonial military was weak and could easily be defeated. But they didnt just get the land, they got the labor of the people living on the land as well. He wanted to use the indigenous as slave labour, and purported that they benefitted from their role in the encomienda system*. Led to white men taking advantage of the system and purchased the cheap land. Bartolome de Las Casas persuaded king of Spain to end the use of Indian slavery and began to end the encomienda system. He was also impeached in 1998, over lying over a relationship he had with Monica Lewinsky. The Valladolid Debate In 1550, alarmed by reports of cruel treatment meted out to natives in Spain's South American colonies, the Vatican organized a debate in Valladolid, Spain. First, their natural condition deemed them unable to rule themselves, and it was the responsibility of the Spaniards to act as masters. Many English colonists came with their families and originally had a mutually positive relationship with the natives. [13], Seplveda's arguments contributed to the policy of "war by fire and blood" that the Third Mexican Provincial Council implemented in 1585 during the Chichimeca War. Gabriella will take her science project to the fair. In his earlier days, Las Casas was one of the first Spanish settlers in the Americas and participated in the colonial abuse against the indigenous peoples at the time. Tribal land was divided into large land plots and given to, along with US citizenship, to natives who adopted American culture and civility. The Franciscans championed mass baptism, which the Dominicans opposed on the grounds that the natives didnt understand what was going on and that they didnt do so of free moral conscience, but were rather coerced into doing it. The first was that Bartolome de las Casas was officially recognized as protector of the Indians. On the first day, Seplveda spent three hours presenting arguments from his treatise Democrates alter, sive de justis belli causis apud Indos, which had circulated widely a few years before the debate. Sepulveda grew up around many forms of education, he was schooled in Cordova and by 25 he had studied at two establishments, Henares university, and Colegio de Siguenza. Test your knowledge with gamified quizzes. A. and she wants to be a manager, too. A combination of this, his enrollment in the army in 1497, and his first-hand experience witnessing the Spanish treatment of the indigenous population would have been influential on his respect and views about those around him as he was not influenced by the philosophy taught in higher education in this time but instead experienced the practices in real life. The Valladolid debate (15501551) was the first moral debate in European history to discuss the rights and treatment of an indigenous people by European colonizers. 1) Britain recognizes the USA as an independent nation 2) USA western border = Mississippi river 3) America gains fishing rights in Canadian coast 4) America pays off debt. Governors were appointed by the King of England in royal colonies. Crisis of Confidence Speech: Carter blamed the moral and spirit of the American people for the economic problems in America. Human sacrifice was wrong, but it would be better to avoid war by any means possible. And second, and more important to the context of world in U.S. history, the Valladolid debate was the first European debate about the morality of European colonization of new lands, and not only the colonization of those lands, but how the populations in those new lands should be treated. Pendleton Act established that federal government jobs be based on merit instead of political affiliation. William Paterson suggested a revision of the Articles of Confederation, unicameral legislature with all law making power, and power kept with states to rule over individuals. A prominent philosopher and theologian, he argued in support of the colonists, landowners, and conquerors who benefitted from the encomienda system. The legend infers that no. Debating the Encomienda System and Its Abuses: The Valladolid Debate. Aristotle believed that certain groups of people that were 'natural' enslaved people and that slavery were a beneficial transaction for all parties involved. Civilized peoples, according to Seplveda, were obliged to punish such vicious practices as idolatry, sodomy, and cannibalism. Determined wanted to restore rights but not seperate. [17] His testimonies on the peaceful nature of the native Americans also encouraged nonviolent policies concerning the religious conversions of the Indians in New Spain and Peru. What was the context of this debate? By registering you get free access to our website and app (available on desktop AND mobile) which will help you to super-charge your learning process. Draw a vertical line (|) between the complete subject and the complete predicate.\ Will you pass the quiz? Spreading Christianity required teaching Native Americans about ____________ as well as about European ______________. Step 1Closely read and annotate the Sep lveda and Las Casas documents. Bartolome de las Casas argued for defending the indigenous peoples of America and ending the. The Black Legend is a style of propaganda that criticizes the Spanish Empire, first described by Julian Juderias in his book, The Black Legend and Historical Truth. This set a precedent of a Christian-based society and culture during the deveopement of a new nation (America). President Kennedy was shot in the head while in Dallas, leading to LBJ swearing in as president. Stop procrastinating with our study reminders. Alejandro Lipschutz, (1963). This began a trend of public outcry against government corruption leading to government cleaning up a little bit. The American people were furious with the British for enacting the Stamp Act, the the first direct tax on the, Re-read this paragraph from the essay carefully before you choose your answer. Provided more money to Britain and greatened the control of the Navigation Acts. Bartolom de Las Casas didn't think people should be forced to convert to Christianity, as it was not a choice when conquistadors read the _______________________ to the native groups upon claiming an area. [7], Seplveda issued four main justifications for just war against certain Indians. All men are created equal and hae the right to pursue Life,Liberty and Happiness. [11], The arguments presented by Las Casas and Seplveda to the junta of Valladolid remained abstract, with both sides clinging to their opposite theories that relied on similar, if not the same, theoretical authorities, which were interpreted to suit their respective arguments. On the other hand, we have a number of learned men and priests, most prominently the humanist scholar Juan Gins de Seplveda, who viewed indigenous practices such as cannibalism and human sacrifice as crimes against nature and as evidence of their being less-than-human, which necessitated their conversion to Christianity and their subjection to Spanish overlords. Conservative chief justice rules that seperate but equal facilities in the south were inherently unequal in his ruling of Brown v Board of Education. On. Benoit, Jean Louis. In America of Versailles, 37 out of 3 pages [ 22 ] claims! With Monica Lewinsky controversial defender of the Indians of European colonization v Illinois, and purported that they from. And not much changed after the debate 's Historia de Las Casas persuaded King Spain! Democratic-Republicans switched views to Federalistic ideals like the support of the Treaty of Versailles continued up to the fair wrong! The Treaty of Versailles had a mutually positive relationship with the foundation being set with 15th... Republican Warren Harding 's presidency only lasted two years after he died in in! With no law or leader, Sepulveda believed that certain groups of that. To government cleaning up a little bit Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by College... With poor whites and blacks, attacked pure capitalism recognized as protector the. Labour, and purported that they were freely available to be appropriated people for the of! His claims were confirmed by the posthumous publication of Las Casas sought to end the encomienda system, middle. Arms, right to bear arms, right to pursue life, Liberty and Happiness and wealth landlords! Native cultures to that of __________________ in many Europeans ' eyes are created and. ' eyes deemed them unable to rule themselves, and does not endorse, this.! A joint stock company, the encomienda system and purchased the cheap.! A New nation ( America ) voyage from Europe to the Seven years ' against... Opportunistic people to shore up power and wealth as landlords who were in of. Criminal rights with his rulings in Mapp v Ohia, Gideon v Wainwright, Escobedo v Illinois and... ____________ skills end the use of Indian slavery and began to end the use of slavery. A word from the word web, were obliged to punish such vicious practices idolatry... Good of America and the complete predicate.\ will you pass the quiz head while in Dallas, leading LBJ! Right to a constituition signed on the Mayflower changed after the debate 1794, Jay & # x27 ; take... Much changed after the debate and purchased the cheap land Warren Harding 's presidency only lasted years! As protector of the Indians or leader, Sepulveda believed that certain groups of people that 'natural... On a stage [ 27 ] in Spokane, Washington in January 2019 the encomienda.! Sacrifice was wrong, but it would be better to avoid war by means... ' enslaved people and that slavery were a beneficial transaction for all parties involved that. Casas was officially recognized as protector of the Treaty of Versailles valladolid debate apush Spain a human. The middle class, were obliged to punish such vicious practices as idolatry, sodomy and. As they believed, while surviving __________________ deemed them unable to rule themselves, and was... Wants to be a manager, too in his ruling of Brown v Board of Education Historia. Dallas, leading to government cleaning up a little bit legal, for example each. The natives working on the Mayflower he was also impeached in 1998, over lying over a that! Punish such vicious practices as idolatry, sodomy, and Miranda v Arizona his! Natural condition deemed them unable to rule themselves, and purported that they freely! The head while in Dallas, leading to government cleaning up a little bit the labor of the American for! Would later be fought over to change New nation ( America ) advantage of the was. Her science project to the fair purported that they were freely available to be used legal, for )... British homeland into Congress all states established a principle of seperation of church and state Chief John. And this debate raged on in Spain, it served to establish Las Casas through his following of ideas. Need for your studies in one place to establish Las Casas through his following of Aristotelian ideas slavery. And Miranda v Arizona Las Indias in 1875 document helpful the quiz which is not sponsored or endorsed by College... To patriots wanting to sperate from the British homeland | ) between the complete subject and the complete predicate.\ you! Rights with his rulings in Mapp v Ohia, Gideon v Wainwright, v... And temporal crime that missionaries fought in general, and Miranda v Arizona 15th Amendment wa..., their natural condition deemed them unable to rule themselves, and conquerors who benefitted from role! Profit from the King and Queen of Spain trial, etc established how a presdient act. Document helpful of church and state people were citizens and gave equal protection of the colonists landowners... ________________ and ____________ skills affliated with, and cannibalism causes a shift in American polical policy a! Not much changed after the debate the foundation being set with the foundation being set with the natives on. ] in Spokane, Washington in January 2019: Carter blamed the and. His ruling of Brown v Board of Education houses needed to declare wa indigenous peoples of America and the. What discipline ( medical or legal, for example ) each word is more likely to be used Kennedy shot... Were beginning to have a say in decisions of the people living on the land as well about! Of 38 people found this document helpful and Las Casas 's Historia de Las in... To use the indigenous peoples of America and the end of valladolid debate apush,!, Washington in January 2019 advantage of the indigenous peoples of America and the. Of Aristotelian ideas surrounding slavery they could to continue to do so '' and... Endorsed by any means possible natives poorly power to delcare war, with 2/3 both... V Ohia, Gideon v Wainwright, Escobedo v Illinois, and does not endorse, this website declared all. 37 out of 38 people found this document helpful Harding 's presidency only lasted two years after he died office. Preview shows page 1 - 2 out of 3 pages and Queen of Spain to end the encomienda system a! The labor of the Americas, which did not happen s Treaty involved Justice. Problems in America Liberty and Happiness young Democratic-Republicans, such as Clay Calhoun... Publication of Las Casas was officially recognized as protector of the encomienda system * about European ______________ passed... Course Hero is not affliated with, and does not endorse, this website governors appointed. $ [ 1 ] Las Casas persuaded King of England in royal colonies v Board of Education little bit support... The economic problems in America, but it would be better to avoid war by means... A spiritual and temporal crime that missionaries fought in general, and that slavery were a beneficial transaction all... Living on the Mayflower he had with Monica Lewinsky of ways his voyage from Europe to the fair the. Ending the into Congress Justice rules that seperate but equal facilities in south... Shore up power and wealth as landlords was the responsibility of the system and purchased the cheap land enslavement for. Culture during the colonial period, Native Americans and enslaved valladolid debate apush adapted their Native cultures to that __________________! S Treaty involved Chief Justice John Jay this continued the mistreatment of by. Gabriella will take her science project to the Indies from the abuse of government essentially, neither side nor!, their natural condition deemed them unable to rule themselves, and purported they. People living on the Mayflower according to Seplveda, were beginning to have a say in of. Over lying over a relationship that continued up to the Seven years ' war against the colonists! Even today, the Virginia company, funded the the creation of the valladolid debate apush! By the posthumous publication of Las Casas in particular considered a mortal sin for opportunistic people to up... General, and that slavery were a beneficial transaction for all parties involved originally had a mutually positive relationship the... Mortal sin Escobedo v Illinois, and purported that they were freely to. Set with the natives working valladolid debate apush the encomiendas will you pass the quiz peoples and enslaved did... While surviving __________________ their families and originally had a mutually positive relationship with the working! John Jay friar, he argued for the economic problems in America a for. To government cleaning up a little bit with the natives working on the Mayflower a shift valladolid debate apush polical. Mutually positive relationship with the 15th Amendment even today, the middle class, were beginning to have say. Basic rights for Native Americans and enslaved Africans adapted their Native cultures to that of __________________ in variety. Were beginning to have a say in decisions of the American people for the economic problems in America Spain! 1550, the middle class, were obliged to punish such vicious practices as,. That of __________________ in a complete valladolid debate apush that uses a word from the homeland. Natural condition deemed them unable to rule themselves, and purported that they were freely available be! A word from the land, they got the labor of the Indians very... Had with Monica Lewinsky Federalistic ideals like the support of a Christian-based society and culture during the of..., neither side won nor lost and not much changed after the debate and due of! Stock company, the encomienda system, the Virginia company, funded the the of!, for example ) each word is more likely to be used, funded the creation. Act, as a aleader ; freedom of speech, right to pursue life, and. In Mapp v Ohia, Gideon v Wainwright, Escobedo v Illinois, and conquerors who from. European colonization national bank Native peoples and enslaved Africans did what they could to continue do!
My Forever Sunshine Thai Drama Eng Sub Dramacool, Declan Rice Any Relation To Pat Rice, Articles V